The Role of Biodegradable and Compostable Alternatives
When designed, certified and used appropriately, biodegradable and compostable agricultural plastics have the potential to play a significant role in enhancing the sustainability of agricultural systems. This is particularly the case where product recovery after use is technically challenging, economically impractical, or associated with a high risk of environmental leakage. However, this can only be fully achieved if compliance with regulations on use of mulch films is adhered to. Uncertainties around performance, degradation processes and environmental impacts remain.
In the stakeholder survey, support was strongest for biodegradable applications for mulch films and other non-recoverable products, including certain tree guards and coated agricultural inputs. Respondents recognised their potential to simplify end-of-life management, reduce the risk of plastic leakage and complement existing collection and recycling systems. At the same time, stakeholders highlighted the importance of maintaining high standards of environmental performance, transparency and product stewardship. However, concerns among MINAGRIS consortium remain regarding, transparency around additives and the potential effects of degradation products in soil ecosystems. The importance of compliance with recognised international standards and legislation was emphasised. Again building user knowledge and awareness was identified as essential.
Governance Matters
These challenges show how governance is a critical factor in reducing microplastic pollution. The current legislative landscape is seen as fragmented and only partly effective.
Successful policy frameworks are likely to require:
- Strong monitoring, data availability on production and end-of-life of plastics materials and enforcement mechanisms.
- Well-designed economic incentives.
- Better knowledge sharing and dissemination.
- Meaningful stakeholder engagement across the value chain.
- Harmonised approaches to producer responsibility and collection systems.
- Compliance in the market with the EU and international regulatory framework for biodegradable plastics.
Areas of Broad Consensus
Despite differences in evidence and perspective between researchers, policy makers, farmers, industry representatives and NGOs expressed in the literature and in the surveys conducted, several common themes emerged:
- Knowledge gaps remain a major obstacle: Better data (covering all the value chain), monitoring systems and evidence are essential for effective policy development and evaluation, while industry and users need awareness raising and advice.
- Economical sustainability of the recycling system: economic feasibility of recycling both in terms of process and price of final products is important.
- End-of-life management is a priority: Investment in collection and recycling infrastructure is widely seen as the most immediate opportunity for reducing plastic leakage.
- Eco-design is critical: Products should be designed with their entire lifecycle in mind, including recovery, recycling and disposal.
- Extended Producer Responsibility is strongly supported: Harmonised EPR schemes and national collection systems are critically needed.
A Systems-Based Path Forward
The evidence is clear: reducing microplastic pollution in agricultural soils will require coordinated action across the entire value chain. No single technology or intervention can solve the problem. End-of-life management is a priority, a combination of better design, optimized and environmentally sustainable use of plastics, and appropriate biodegradable alternatives will also be needed.
A successful strategy must combine lifecycle thinking, stakeholder collaboration, robust governance, improved monitoring and practical solutions for plastic use and end-of-life management. Only through a systems-based approach can Europe effectively reduce microplastic emissions while maintaining the benefits that plastics provide to modern agriculture.
Footnote About the BREF
The BREF (Best Available Techniques Reference) document has been developed to provide scientific and technical guidance on the sustainable use of plastics in agriculture, with a particular focus on preventing and reducing micro- and nanoplastic emissions to soils and connected ecosystems. It is intended as a practical reference for growers, industry stakeholders, technical advisers, policy makers and standardisation bodies. It sets out 8 Best Available Techniques. Read the document by clicking here.